Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
Correspondence re: Building Inspections 2009
STATE OF CONNECTICUT DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DIVISION OF FIRE,EMERGENCY AND BUILDING SERVICES April 22, 2009 Mr. David Jensen Montville Assistant Building Official 310 Norwich New London Turnpike Uncasville, CT 06384 Re: Appeal of State Building Inspector's decision re M-153-09 re 36 Platoz Drive, Uncasville, CT —A-28-09 Dear Mr. Jensen: Per your letter dated April 16, 2009, the above appeal has been withdrawn. Sincerely, ‘#(4/4 ohn Butkus, Panel Chair State Codes and Standards Committee c: Lisa Humble, OSBI John Mandes (Owner) Vernon Vesey II, Montville Building Official Terry Brouwer, OSFM Michael Sinsigalli Debbie Sampson Henry Miga, Alternate Janet K. Ainsworth, Esquire Telephone(860)685-8310 1111 Country Club Road Middletown,CT 06457 http://www.ct.gov/dps An Equal Opportunity Employer Town of Montville c 310 Norwich-New London Tpke. Uncasville, Ct. 06382 „ecE►V6-4 Li APR 1 6 2009 71, OFFICE OF 4/16/09 _..__<96'� .zc� ... CS C MM_ State Codes and Standards Committee . j 1111 Country Club Rd. CAIIONS Middletown, Ct. 06457 1 Mn Page Re: Request for appeal of State Building Inspector's decision re M-152-09 and M-153-09 re 36 and 46 Platoz Dr., Uncasville, Ct - A-28-09 After consulting with the State Fire Marshal and State Building Inspector on April 15, 2009, I have decided to withdraw my request for appeal of the above referenced decision of the State Building Inspector. David M. Jensen Assistant Building Inspector Cc: File , r, . �r li$ti Town of Montville dr ,> ac 310 Norwich-New London Tpke. Uncasville, Ct. 06382 \ tt 'y 3/30/09 To: Mayor Jaskiewicz From Vern Vesey, Building Official On February 18, 2009, the owners of the properties at 36 and 46 Platoz Dr. applied for modification of the Connecticut Building Code requirement for installation of sprinkler systems in two, eight unit apartment buildings. As required during the modification process I sent my comments to the State Building Inspector. For safety reasons I did not support the request. The Fire Marshal agrees with my concerns for the safety of the tenants. On March 30, 2009, I received a copy of the State's approval of the request. Per Connecticut General Statute 29-254"Any person aggrieved by any decision of the State Building Inspector may appeal to Codes and Standards within 14 days" I am requesting your permission to seek the advice of counsel as to whether a Building Official or Municipality may appeal the State Building Inspectors decision. If counsel confirms that a Building Official may appeal, I am asking your permission to enlist the services of counsel to pursue such appeal Re :- � ' ernon D. Vesey II Building Official r 1786 Qf� Mita c-) Town of Montville 310 Norwich-New London Tpke. _ Uncasville, Ct. 06382 T\l]� 1.7 f G f Y • 3/31/09 3/31/09 Shipman& Goodwin Counselors at Law Atty. Bruce Chudwick Bruce, Yesterday I faxed you the information concerning my request as to whether or not I am allowed to file an appeal of the State Building Inspector's decision to offer a modification of the sprinkler requirements at 36 and 46 Platoz Dr. in Montville. I am sending this fax to make you aware that the owner of the properties was in today asking if I have received the modification from the State, and when I will be issuing his permits. I told him that I was considering filing an appeal of the modification and asked that he contact me next Monday. I told him I would try to have a decision by then. Please let me know as soon as you decide whether or not I am allowed to file an appeal. Thanks, Vern Vesey, Building Official Office& Voice Mail 860-848-3030 x336 Cell 860-625-7445 Fax 860-848-7231 Cc: Mayor Jaskiewicz File ".`� ii8b 01 rkt Town of Montville 310 Norwich-New London Tpke. Uncasville, Ct. 06382 \ -7400pil Z� Jt :;/ 4/16/09 State Codes and Standards Committee 1111 Country Club Rd. Middletown, Ct. 06457 Re: Request fora appeal of State BuildingInspector's - _ _ PP p s decision re M 152 09 and M-153 09 re 36 and 46 Platoz Dr., Uncasville, Ct - A-28-09 After consulting with the State Fire Marshal and State Building Inspector on April 15, 2009, I have decided to withdraw my request for appeal of the above referenced decision of the State Building Inspector. David M. Jensen Assistant Building Inspector Cc: File E-mailed to Janet.ainsworth@apo.state.ct.us on 4-16-09 1:40 PM 1786 O,ri n� Town of Montville 310 Norwich-New London Tpke. Uncasville, Ct. 06382 4/15/09 State Codes and Standards Committee 1111 Country Club Rd. Middletown, Ct. 06457 Re: Request for appeal of State Building Inspector's decision re M-152-09 and M-153-09 re 36 and 46 Platoz Dr., Uncasville, Ct - A-28-09 We wish to appeal the decision of the State Building Inspector regarding code modifications M-152-09 and M-153 -09, allowing two R-2 uses to be completed without providing sprinkler protection. According to the approvals, her decision is based on the fact that "existing conditions preclude compliance with requirements for new construction and that when the building was originally constructed, sprinkler protection was not required". It is our contention that these structures, which were exterior framed only and then abandoned for over thirty years, are not existing structures according to section 202 (definitions) of the 2003 IBC and section 101.2 of the 2003 IEBC portions of the 2005 Connecticut Building Code. The interior framing of the buildings is not complete and no HVAC, Plumbing or Electrical systems have been installed. There are no existing conditions that preclude compliance with the requirements for new construction regarding sprinkler protection. b:e-eLvd Vernon D. Vesey II David R. Jensen Building Official Assistant Building Official 04/13/2009 14:08 FAX 860 685 8365 "TATE BUILDING INSPECTOR l 002/002 1STATE OF CONNECTICUT y i`, DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DIVISION OF FIRE, EMERGENCY AND BUILDING SERVICES April 8, 2009 CERTIFIED MAIL—RETURN RECEIPT David Jensen Montville Assistant Building Official 310 Norwich New London Turnpike Uncasville, CT 06384 Re: Request for appeal of State Building Inspector's decision re M-153-09 re 36 Platoz Drive, Uncasville, CT—A-28-09 Dear Mr. Jensen: At its meeting of April 8, 2009, the State Codes and Standards Committee granted your request for a hearing regarding your appeal of the approval of the State Building Inspector of a code modification. The hearing will be limited to whether you are aggrieved by this action. The hearing has been scheduled for Wednesday,'April 15, 2009, at 2:30 P.M. and will be held in the third floor conference room (room 348) at 1111 Country Club Road, Middletown, Connecticut. Please use the front door of the building and check in at the desk. Only if you are found to be aggrieved, will there be-a hearing on the merits of your appeal at a later date. A record will be made of the hearing. A written transcript of oral testimony could be made available to you at your expense. Failure by the appellant to appear at the hearing will result In dismissal of the appeal for lack of prosecution. If you have any questions concerning the above, please call (860) 685-8310. Sincerely, J hn Butkus, Panel Chair State Codes and Standards Committee c: Lisa Humble, OSBI John Mandes (Owner) Vernon Vesey II, Montville Building Official Terry Brouwer, OSFM Michael Slnsigalli Debbie Sampson Henry Miga,Alternate Janet K Ainsworth, Esquire Telephone(860)685-8310 1111 Country Club Road Middletown,CT 06457 http://www.ct.gov/dps An Equal Opporruntry Employer STATE OF CONNECTICUT } l DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY sy�� DIVISION OF FIRE,EMERGENCY AND BUILDING SERVICES • • OFFICE OF THE STATE BUILDING INSPECTOR 11 March 25, 2009 Mr. John Mandes 11 Devonshire Drive Waterford, CT 06385 RE: M-153-09 36 Platoz Drive 0 Q Uncasville, Connecticut Dear Mr. Mandes: I have reviewed the referenced request for modification of Section 903.2.7, of the 2003 International Building Code portion of the 2005 State Building Code, which states in part that an automatic sprinkler system installed in accordance with Section 903.3 shall be provided throughout all buildings within a Group R fire area. It is my decision to approve this modification, as requested, and allow an R-2 use building that was partially constructed in late 1960/early 1970 to be completed without providing sprinkler protection with the existing units. This decision is based on existing conditions that preclude compliance with requirements for new construction and the fact that when the building was originally constructed, sprinkler protection was not required. If you have any questions, please contact Daniel Tierney, Deputy State Building Inspector, at (860) 685-8310. Sincerely, O • I ' e Lisa R. Humble, AIA, NCARB State Building Inspector LRH:DT:pm cc: Vernon Vesey, Montville Building Official Terry Brouwer, OSFM Telephone(860)685-8310 1111 Country Club Road Middletown,CT 06457 http://www.ct.gov/dps An Equal Opportunity Employer STATE OF CONNECTICUT DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY Sys© DIVISION OF FIRE,EMERGENCY AND BUILDING SERVICES •7, OFFICE OF THE STATE BUILDING INSPECTOR A March 25, 2009 Mr. John Mandes 11 Devonshire Drive CO o Waterford, CT 06385 RE: M-152-09 46 Platoz Drive Uncasville, Connecticut Dear Mr. Mandes: I have reviewed the referenced request for modification of Section 903.2.7, of the 2003 International Building Code portion of the 2005 State Building Code, which states in part that an automatic sprinkler system installed in accordance with Section 903.3 shall be provided throughout all buildings within a Group R fire area. It is my decision to approve this modification, as requested, and allow an R-2 use building that was partially constructed in late 1960/early 1970 to be completed without providing sprinkler protection with the existing units. This decision is based on existing conditions that preclude compliance with requirements for new construction and the fact that when the building was originally constructed, sprinkler protection was not required. If you have any questions, please contact Daniel Tierney, Deputy State Building Inspector, at (860) 685-8310. Sincerely, 5.17Y77-Mi/k Lisa R. Humble, AIA, NCARB State Building Inspector LRH:DT:pm cc: Vernon Vesey, Montville Building Official Terry Brouwer, OSFM Telephone(860)685-8310 1111 Country Club Road Middletown,CT 06457 httpJ/www.ct.gov/dps An Equal Opportunity Employer c , STATE OF CONNECTICUT FILE# DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY CODES&STANDARDS COMMITTEE 1111 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD MIDDLETOWN,CT 06457 TELEPHONE: (860)685-8310 FAX: (860)685-8365 FOR OFFICE USE ONLY REQUEST FOR APPEAL to the CONNECTICUT CODES AND STANDARDS COMMITTEE In accordance with the provisions of C.G.S. Chapter 541, I (we) (hereinafter referred to as the "Appellant")hereby submit an appeal for relief from a decision of: ❑ Local Building Official (Town/City: ) ❑ Local Fire Marshal (Town/City: ) ❑ Local Building Board of Appeals (Town/City: ) ® State Building Inspector ❑ State Building Inspector together with Office of Protection and Advocacy O State Fire Marshal The Appellant must provide all relevant information. Where information is not available or not relevant to the Appeal,please indicate"N/A." 1. (a) Date of Decision appealed from(Attach copy of letter of decision) 25 Mar.,2009 (b) Name, Address and Telephone Number of Appellee whose decision is being appealed Lisa R. Humble,AIA,NCARB, State Building Inspector, 1111 Country Club Road, Middletown, CT 06457 • 2. Address of Subject Property or Structure 46 Platoz Dr.. Uncasville. CT 06283 Page 1 of 3 REQUEST FOR APPEAL TO THE CODES AND STANDARDS COMMITTEE 3. Name,Address and Telephone Number of Owner of Subject Property John Mandes, 11 Devonshire Drive,Waterford, CT 06385 4. Name, Address and Telephone Number of Appellant The Town of Montville, Building Department, David M. Jensen/ABO, 310 Norwich New London Turnpike,Uncasville, CT 06384, 1-860-848-3030 Ext.335 5. Appellant's relationship to Owner The Town in which the property is located and the Department responsible for oversight of the repairs,maintenance and construction within the Town. 6. Designation: El New Building ® Existing Building El Addition ❑ Alteration ❑ Rehabilitation El Repair ❑ Change in Use El Historic Building(Local, State or Federal Designation) ❑ Other 7. a. Building Use Group (If no Change in Use)R-2 b. If there is a Change in Use, describe current and intended use From to c. Building Construction Classification 5B 8. Size of Building Height(in feet) 24 Feet Number of Stories 2 Total Area 4864 SF Maximum Area per Floor 2,432 SF 9. a. Fire Protection at subject premises(Check appropriate headings) El Smoke Detection ❑ Heat Detection ❑ Extinguishers El Sprinklers El Stand Pipes ® Other(identify) (None) This building has never been occupied for it"s intended use. b. Describe Alarm System(s)at Premises Page 2 of 3 • REQUEST FOR APPEAL TO THE CODES AND STANDARDS COMMA Fl EE (None)This building has naver been occupied for it's intended use. 10. Building Code Section(s) under Appeal 903.2.7 11. Fire Safety Code Section(s)under Appeal N/A 12. Connecticut General Statute Section(s) and Title(s)under Appeal NIA 13. If an additional local, state or federal agency participated in the underlying decision that is the subject of this appeal, please identify those agencies. N/A 14. Relief Requested (Attach supporting data or additional pages, if necessary) Based on Section 101.2 of the 2003 IEBC, Section 903.2.7 of the 2003 IBC appears to apply. The Appellant should be prepared to provide appropriate site and building plans for the hearing panel at the time of such hearing. I, David M. Jensen , certify that the foregoing information is true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. I also certify that I have sent a copy of this completed REQUEST FOR APPEAL form to the Appellee identified above. LI 1 h 109 Signature of A ellant Date STATE OF CONNECTICUT • : ss. C•{\04-c\-\) , 20 Ocj COUNTY OF N e \--v r‘ck0. Personally appeared, \-���\�` V , Signer and Sealer of the foregoing instrument who made oath that the statements herein were true and correct, before me. Page 3 of 3 • REQUEST FOR APPEAL TO THE CODES AND STANDARDS COMMITTEE ommissioner of Superior Court Notary Public NOTE: The appellant is not required to complete this form. However the infor �Lll assist the hearing panel in resolving the appeal. MYCOMMIS&IOP R� OCT 31,2012 FORMS\APPRQST_NET.DOC Rev.324/05 Page 4 of 3 STATE OF CONNECTICUT . • • _ __,--::__.i 1 T DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY S��o DIVISION OF FIRE,EMERGENCY AND BUILDING SERVICES .., ��r,,c OFFICE OF THE STATE BUILDING INSPECTOR =�� March 25, 2009 Mr. John Mandes 11 Devonshire Drive Waterford, CT 06385 RE: M-152-09 46 Platoz Drive Uncasville, Connecticut Dear Mr. Mandes: I have reviewed the referenced request for modification of Section 903.2.7, of the 2003 International Building Code portion of the 2005 State Building Code, which states in part that an automatic sprinkler system installed in accordance with Section 903.3 shall be provided throughout all buildings within a Group R fire area. It is my decision to approve this modification, as requested, and allow an R-2 use building that was partially constructed in late 1960/early 1970 to be completed without providing sprinkler protection with the existing units. This decision is based on existing conditions that preclude compliance with requirements for new construction and the fact that when the building was originally constructed, sprinkler protection was not required. If you have any questions, please contact Daniel Tierney, Deputy State Building Inspector, at (860) 685-8310. Sincerely, r A.* 004 Lisa R. Humble, AIA, NCARB State Building Inspector LRH:DT:pm cc: Vernon Vesey, Montville Building Official Terry Brouwer, OSFM Telephone(860)685-8310 1111 Country Club Road Middletown,CT 06457 http://www.ct.gov/dps An Equal Opportunity Employer N p .0 •C N 2 v Q G L C U E £ o W CL ; • tt cu IA o , W • ctL).1 .7) cram. Illc 2 6 .....1 U Q 2 o VJ O W --- Q N CD N in R G N lL LT LL m mlibi d co '0o a) �y a° 0 Q m m U) W p ¢o $ T m00 0 U 0 U. c me I° m �a W a w CCW W h o 0 a 9h69 9S` T h000 00'LO 900E N O iz2 43) gE k ._x� y C Y C d 2 —i— 'm ` ; ¢ v W ,, W V Ti CC [ a IIIIIr U Q o2 2 > '�0/� V/ CI O R 0 CD_ :ETN W 0 N m N F5 8 3 LL LL l if 2 N N r.. c o a 11'5 Z:5 LL c w a >c *5 T U 4 pWSi ° gcc c� c d Ai- o Ct. W > U �c oS ca 2ZN om m - gE 3E o yx m M cI W E • to.- c° a o Qm E o ¢v Nv ~ m0 co LL = U o LL c I. m m0. s N w Qw O Zii o U a 0969 95TT h000 00T0 900L e STATE OF CONNECTICUT FILE# DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY CODES&STANDARDS COMMITTEE 1111 COUNTRY CLUB ROAD MIDDLETOWN, CT 06457 TELEPHONE: (860)685-8310 FAX: (860)685-8365 FOR OFFICE USE ONLY REQUEST FOR APPEAL to the CONNECTICUT CODES AND STANDARDS COMMITTEE In accordance with the provisions of C.G.S. Chapter 541, I (we) (hereinafter referred to as the "Appellant")hereby submit an appeal for relief from a decision of: ❑ Local Building Official (Town/City: ) ❑ Local Fire Marshal (Town/City: ) ❑ Local Building Board of Appeals (Town/City: ) ® State Building Inspector ❑ State Building Inspector together with Office of Protection and Advocacy ❑ State Fire Marshal The Appellant must provide all relevant information. Where information is not available or not relevant to the Appeal, please indicate"N/A." 1. (a) Date of Decision appealed from (Attach copy of letter of decision) 25 Mar.,2009 (b) Name, Address and Telephone Number of Appellee whose decision is being appealed Lisa R. Humble,AIA,NCARB, State Building Inspector, 1111 Country Club Road, Middletown, CT 06457 2. Address of Subject Property or Structure 36 Platoz Dr.,Uncasville, CT 06283 Page 1 of 3 REQUEST FOR APPEAL TO THE CODES AND STANDARDS COMMITTEE 3. Name,Address and Telephone Number of Owner of Subject Property John Mandes, 11 Devonshire Drive, Waterford, CT 06385 4. Name, Address and Telephone Number of Appellant The Town of Montville, Building Department, David M. Jensen/ABO, 310 Norwich New London Turnpike, Uncasville, CT 06384, 1-860-848-3030 Ext.335 5. Appellant's relationship to Owner The Town in which the property is located and the Department responsible for oversight of the repairs,maintenance and construction within the Town. 6. Designation: ❑ New Building ® Existing Building ❑ Addition ❑ Alteration ❑ Rehabilitation ❑ Repair ❑ Change in Use ❑ Historic Building (Local, State or Federal Designation) ❑ Other 7. a. Building Use Group(If no Change in Use)R-2 b. If there is a Change in Use, describe current and intended use From to c. Building Construction Classification 5B 8. Size of Building Height(in feet) 24 Feet Number of Stories 2 Total Area 4864 SF Maximum Area per Floor 2,432 SF 9. a. Fire Protection at subject premises(Check appropriate headings) ❑ Smoke Detection ❑ Heat Detection ❑ Extinguishers ❑ Sprinklers ❑ Stand Pipes ® Other(identify) (None) This building has never been occupied for it"s intended use. b. Describe Alarm System(s) at Premises Page 2 of 3 REQUEST FOR APPEAL TO THE CODES AND STANDARDS COMMITTEE (None)This building has naver been occupied for it's intended use. 10. Building Code Section(s)under Appeal 903.2.7 11. Fire Safety Code Section(s)under Appeal N/A 12. Connecticut General Statute Section(s) and Title(s) under Appeal NIA 13. If an additional local, state or federal agency participated in the underlying decision that is the subject of this appeal, please identify those agencies. N/A 14. Relief Requested (Attach supporting data or additional pages, if necessary) Based on Section 101.2 of the 2003 IEBC, Section 903.2.7 of the 2003 IBC appears to apply. The Appellant should be prepared to provide appropriate site and building plans for the hearing panel at the time of such hearing. I, David M. Jensen , certify that the foregoing information is true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. I also certify that I have sent a copy of this completed REQUEST FOR APPEAL form to the Appellee identified above. /7/%' 9 Signature of Ap ellant Date STATE OF CONNECTICUT : ss.1`5 ��iti��Q4a111_,20 o9 COUNTY OF keno r c80 N : Personally appeared, C'-V.D-NG\ , Signer and Sealer of the foregoing instrument who made oath that the statements herein were true and correct, before me. Page 3 of 3 REQUEST FOR APPEAL TO THE CODES AND STANDARDS COMMITTEE J - ommissioner of Superior Court Notary Public NOTE: The appellant is not required to complete this form. However the information provided will assist the hearing panel in resolving the appeaL LIP� FORMSVIPPRQST_NET.DOC P9Y CO M SSIONSAEXRTERRE O CT 11 2O 74 Rev.3124/05 Page 4 of 3 , STATE OF CONNECTICUT DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY rs�� DIVISION OF FIRE,EMERGENCY AND BUILDING SERVICES .•• �� OFFICE OF THE STATE BUILDING INSPECTOR March 25, 2009 Mr. John Mandes 11 Devonshire Drive Waterford, CT 06385 RE: M-153-09 36 Platoz Drive Uncasville, Connecticut Dear Mr. Mandes: I have reviewed the referenced request for modification of Section 903.2.7, of the 2003 International Building Code portion of the 2005 State Building Code, which states in part that an automatic sprinkler system installed in accordance with Section 903.3 shall be provided throughout all buildings within a Group R fire area. It is my decision to approve this modification, as requested, and allow an R-2 use building that was partially constructed in late 1960/early 1970 to be completed without providing sprinkler protection with the existing units. This decision is based on existing conditions that preclude compliance with requirements for new construction and the fact that when the building was originally constructed, sprinkler protection was not required. If you have any questions, please contact Daniel Tierney, Deputy State Building Inspector, at (860) 685-8310. Sincerely, 4 Lisa R. Humble, AIA, NCARB State Building Inspector LRH:DT:pm cc: Vernon-Vesey, Montville Building Official. Terry Brouwer, OSFM Telephone(860)685-8310 1111 Country Club Road Middletown, CT 06457 http://www.ct.gov/dps An Equal Opportunity Employer o a) - ( { - i pi ■ e 5 is 1 a. O. 7 W 2 \ u 0 Q ; - _ 11111 !\ z.k-ii c as Lu k ; r } /ƒ )\ "}m LT ■ ) Zy I o § po ti i £ 2\i \ f, ( §) < / B I ,-, e a $o ecI § _b k/ To 'CsC0 k /� \o 6E69 9SVE h000 00TO 900L ƒ ,115 Ici ( • _ } kt k= �.� § ) II 7 | ƒ W 2 U 3 f , c 4114, 2Ea � \ r so a)OJ1IIip Li Ci) CI §) CO Ta � kk ® CV co ■ L ■ . g _ .\ % 0 § > ° \ k� k§ /, k © � un o 2� 6 \ \03 0- \ ) k (c£ ® r «& o T. ESQ@ 9STT h000 OO'EO 900L STATE OF CONNECTICUT 1 ( DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DIVISION OF FIRE,EMERGENCY AND BUILDING SERVICES 41)1:2,- April 7, 2009 Mr. David Jensen Montville Assistant Building Official 310 Norwich New London Turnpike Uncasville, CT 06384 Re: Request for appeal of State Building Inspector's decision re M-153-09 re 36 Platoz Drive, Uncasville, CT —A-28-09 Dear Mr. Jensen: The Codes and Standards Committee received your appeal on April 7, 2009. You will be notified when a hearing date has been scheduled. This hearing will also address the aggrievement issue. The parties are advised that the appeal file ordinarily is limited to information that has been submitted by a party to the appeal. Information submitted to a local building official, a local fire marshal, the State Building Inspector, the State Fire Marshal or the Office of Protection and Advocacy for Persons with Disabilities is not automatically transferred to the Codes and Standards Committee when an appeal is filed. If you wish particular information to be considered by the appeal panel assigned to your case, you must submit it to the Codes and Standards Committee. The parties are further advised that they must copy all parties of record when submitting documentation to the Committee. If you have any questions, please call (860) 685-8310. Sincerely, sii9/141/' 46014,14 ohn Butkus, Chair Codes and Standards Committee Enclosures c: John Mandes Lisa Humble, OSBI Vernon Vesey, Montville Building Official Terry Brouwer, OSFM Telephone(860)685-8310 1111 Country Club Road Middletown,CT 06457 http://www.ct.gov/dps An Equal Opportunity Employer STATE OF CONNECTICUT Codes and Standards Committee 1111 Country Club Road, Middletown, CT 06457 FILING PROCEDURE FOR APPEALS TO CONNECTICUT CODES AND STANDARDS COMMITTEE MEETING DATES The Committee conducts regular meetings on the second Wednesday of every month, except on legal holidays and during the months of February and July. INITIATING APPEALS An appeal may be initiated by sending written notice by U.S. mail, email or fax to the Office of the Codes and Standards Committee, Department of Public Safety, 1111 Country Club Road, Middletown, CT 06457-2389 (FAX 860-685-8365). The deadlines for filing a timely appeal are listed below and also may be found, along with other pertinent information, on the Statutory Authority Matrix. Please note that the statutory filing deadlines are mandatory. The Committee does not have authority to consider the merits of a late appeal. The voluntary Request for Appeal to the Connecticut Codes and Standards Committee questionnaire form should be returned within 14 days of receiving it, or as soon as practicable, so that the Appeal Panel assigned to the appeal will have sufficient information at the time of the hearing. However, your appeal is considered filed upon receipt of a letter or other written notice indicating that you wish to file an appeal. It is not necessary to file the Request for Appeal to the Connecticut Codes and Standards Committee in order for your appeal to be processed. Upon receipt of the appeal, the Codes and Standards Committee will assign a file number and will schedule a hearing 30 days or more from the regular meeting next following the date of receipt. All future correspondence to the Committee should reference the file number. STATUTORY APPEAL PERIODS 29-252—within 14 days after mailing of the decision by the State Building Inspector 29-252a— not later than 7 days after issuance of the decision by the State Building Inspector 29-254—within 14 days after mailing the decision by the State Building Inspector 29-269(b)—within 30 days after decision rendered by State Building Inspector and executive director of Office of Protection and Advocacy for Persons with Disabilities 29-200(d)—within 30 days after decision rendered by State Building Inspector and executive director of Office of Protection and Advocacy for Persons with Disabilities 29-266(b)—within 14 days after filing of the decision by the Building Board of Appeals with the building official 29-266(c)—within 14 days after filing of notice by the Building Board of Appeals with the building official u _ y Lo C L -- C p O o) MO - U) .O •U C c 9- -o - - . ' M U (p Y co C co C_O C > (U a) U C (a N Lf) 0 C U C p U (o ' ,.Q (o LL O () - - C = C .O L U (. 'C a Q m U) (1) U) (o V) C .0 3 -o N = a U U) U 0.— U >' a)t 0.. Q +�_.. >, U U a io E o � .c o -cw/) o <W o Q CO Q << > 77 .E 73 LL it _ .0 c 0) aC)) — co >, a) 0 L.L. U) C U) — O C CO c) � � ° cam > (o p m a) o a) U) (p .0 L p - - C - C - t C p '� a O >- o) Q Q - >,0 U ` U ac) aai ax) c < -o co < (t n < < > E D U- 0 E o a) a) s �) M c c a 4- O LL •-„_ O a)— .-r CD o O O CW t .C_ (o C N (n c p U L as a) (o CO C aa)) `" 5aa)) ac) ;= ..' aa)iuo�i ° *- a) na� (n L O p o a) o_.5 2 >, > (0 0-� T Z 0 p L L c ca 0- O LL C a) (o .. 0.LL (o U U) 0c,' Q (o (n < DJ < D .0 o < J > 0 i.L CD COiO 0 a) L NCO .- V O -0 w � p t - O ... (a N - IS .� p p L C (o w s c > _ C >, Qp 1E (na)0 . - C CL a) C 0)t 00 CO >> > 'C >+ U � LL °U < -00 CO < co Q a. 0 co > 'D (t .0 LL to0 O m O c O c > m .- .r Q O� N .O (p .O a) a) - c (o m o In a) (n T Q p 1E (n Q1 C a) u > .U) Q (.) CU >, La)C O CQ >, Cm p > a) pm Qpm C 0) ay 1.- CO a) _ >, Q) 0 CC z3 co Q -a CO < co Q a_ 0 CO > -0 -0 o L L a_ c v Q c � U) �) c 0 0 -a N N U (o a) > (n L J _O C D U) a > OM > p N a) O� J > 73 UN U N E in o > 3 . (o < PCr) < (o Q U) a_ OQd > -o < E a) LL < a) fa _ m #� m ti p E /� C U) -0 C --Cr) yi�� No 0 a 10 . '- _ mU N U _ (o .� oa ` p C (� .� N .Q L Qp iU) DQUs U V Cr) o O U O fl T ) am (7) Ui Qpm c a (o m Q L $ D) a3 i) a) ct c pp ° -o U CO Q z G) Q co Q i!) Q a O Q Q> v a L // _ (o (c c aU) Ci) as Ea (n C C O 0 N O (� O a) z3 CO (o ilty X (Nil' O 0 += p v p a .� E U) w N ira CL a) a O (moo ° C > (C6 � N > a) (ten °>" o i3 N @m > C (o .2 a) p U C D U) � _a o 3 o CO N a) L D U) a) u) L T Q U) L L L (n (o C .a.)>_Q U) D a) E Q'U — >, m-c p C Q a) a) 0 p > w lip 2 C7 ^ a) 0 -a O0 ' 3 Qa) m c 0) (o L 3 Q (n > U CC °) o 0 co co < -a U) < co Q Cl- o < (o Q E a) 3 a$ w o via ce N p73 (n U H Y! N 'D L O Q O -o ,- E a) U �// 0 • mO ° cm _° c > 0 t - CO—co > ) O. E N U �i O L (o .0 U) m U) p C (o . •U) 0 p 3 Q) U) p U) cp .(n 'C > Q C a) E (n U) C (o C 4) a) (6 w C = 0 co a) a) 0 Qpm c (y) as mm L > Q > (a a) 0) (n p > a'�� a ZZ Q U 13 U) CQ -0 CO < -o (/) < (o Q U) ma_ O < > -0 o < E a) 0 Lcu o 0 > ((3 m (n (n o c O Cl) c c c a) '-1— r c >, a) a C c (a c i.. E E o0 _ O 0• E a 42) d d F. a� criR = Nw H O V C d 0 •5 U •5 3 d 'C H I- 0 �5, 7 0 a) i. C. O U) U) Q a) �„� Cl) Cr) a T 0 5 . 5 Q (a Z D U) I Z (c .0 _ STATE OF CONNECTICUT ) (� DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC SAFETY DIVISION OF FIRE,EMERGENCY AND BUILDING SERVICES 4r April 8, 2009 CERTIFIED MAIL— RETURN RECEIPT David Jensen Montville Assistant Building Official 310 Norwich New London Turnpike Uncasville, CT 06384 Re: Request for appeal of State Building Inspector's decision re M-153-09 re 36 Platoz Drive, Uncasville, CT—A-28-09 Dear Mr. Jensen: At its meeting of April 8, 2009, the State Codes and Standards Committee granted your request for a hearing regarding your appeal of the approval of the State Building Inspector of a code modification. The hearing will be limited to whether you are aggrieved by this action. The hearing has been scheduled for Wednesday, April 15, 2009, at 2:30 P.M. and will be held in the third floor conference room (room 348) at 1111 Country Club Road, Middletown, Connecticut. Please use the front door of the building and check in at the desk. Only if you are found to be aggrieved, will there be a hearing on the merits of your appeal at a later date. A record will be made of the hearing. A written transcript of oral testimony could be made available to you at your expense. Failure by the appellant to appear at the hearing will result in dismissal of the appeal for lack of prosecution. If you have any questions concerning the above, please call (860) 685-8310. Sincerely, n1/1741/ - J hn Butkus, Panel Chair State Codes and Standards Committee c: Lisa Humble, OSBI John Mandes (Owner) Vernon Vesey II, Montville Building Official Terry Brouwer, OSFM Michael Sinsigalli Debbie Sampson Henry Miga, Alternate Janet K. Ainsworth, EsquireTelephone(860)685-8310 1111 Country Club Road Middletown,CT 06457 http://www.ct.gov/dps An Equal Opportunity Employer lig* C1 n .0 rri C7 Cr) H n ^ n ? V t R. clO ci i ro O.1 • < 'ria H i•Fi ,•.; cWo - VI mp O v = o ti oZ < Q o — CD CD = S••y CDD CD EI EI _ + `•� C •- is • \IN.,' CQ D o urwTFos . O oNE 9A T rn '0 >410 ;kr O10 il mNW aN m � o 9092_ 5690 7000 06fT 2.0Od. 11 11 1 111111 11 W171 VW 0314111130 3NI1 a3iO4 IV O10d'SR3tlO.• ,., - - - 1H_ i • - r Iiiivn 1 iii-e- pa/L-ce-gc 1.4)-0_, - 1.-e.., r.-e_ia.(_ gni n U,/e.-rte 1 • Property Owner : MANDES ARTEMIS Address &- City, State, ZIP: `bJa , C 042385- Surveyed 42385Surveyed by : NG Date of Survey : 4/3/91 Occupancy: Multiple Residence Floor Area : 4 ,736 square feet Number of stories: 2 . 0 Class: Frame Average story height : 9.0 feet Cost rank: Low Effective age: 2 years Cost as of : 10/91 Units Cost Total Basic structure cost 4 ,736 29. 42 139,333 Basement: Unfinished Basement 2,304 14 . 04 32,348 Building Cost New 4 ,736 36. 25 171 ,681 Less Depreciation: Physical <35.0%> <60,088> Functional <45.0%> <77 ,256> Total Depreciation <80. 0%> <137 , 344> Depreciated Cost 34,337 Miscellaneous: Land 39,300 Total 73,637 Rounded to nearest $100 73, 600 Cost data by MARSHALL and SWIFT LOCATION : 46 PLATOZ DR M/L: 33/17J LAND: 0.65ac ZONE: R-20 [NON-CONF . COMM USE] AGE : 1971 REMARKS: SHELL ONLY SINCE 1971 [45% UNFIN CONSTR] LAND PRICING: SITE : 0 . 46ac = $64000 - 40% = $38400 EXC/REAR: 0. 19ac @ $ 5000/ac = $900 PROFILE 57 t 1 is Property Owner : MANDES ARTEMIS Address : ii per+ /.0,,. ;; City , State, ZIP: W Cf, p6,3e5-- Surveyed by : NG !_ Date of Survey : 4/3/91 3'> Occupancy: Multiple Residence Floor Area: 4 ,736 square feet Number of stories: 2. 0 Class: Frame Average story height: 9.0 feet Cost rank: Low Effective age : 12 years Cost as of : 10/91 i Units Cost Total Basic structure cost 4 , 736 29. 42 139, 333 , Basement: Unfinished Basement 2,304 14 .04 32, 348 °' Building Cost New 4 ,736 36 .25 171 ,681 Less Depreciation: Physical <35. 0%> <60,088> 4 Functional <45. 0%> <77,256> Total Depreciation <80. 0%> <137,344> Depreciated Cost 34,337 Miscellaneous: Land 39, 400 Total 73,737 I Rounded to nearest $100 73, 700 Cost data by MARSHALL and SWIFT 4: LOCATION : 36 PLATOZ DR M/L : 33/17K F LAND: 0.66ac ZONE : R-20 [NON-CONF . COMM USE] AGE : 1970 REMARKS: SHELL ONLY SINCE 1971 [BLDG BOARDED UP + VANDALIZED] D/B/A: VACANT TO BE 4 UNITS LAND PRICING: SITE : 0.46ac = $64000 - 40% = $38400 EXC/REAR : 0.20ac @ $5000/ac = $1000 PROFILE 56 f I k; is f r 1 pp 7 r co s I O N r O N C N r O N to; O y r p cn r C r O O ¢ r -. m r O 0 U r -1 m F-• O O U r J m r O O U H -� m r O C H FO r O O < 0 0 _. H z a ,- 0 0 _J H z < o 0 of y z - or c o _I y z a or c o o H z a - 3 0 ,-- Z .... 0 z r 0 O -, y - Q r F I. I 1 I 1 V W61 I 6I. I 6l I 61 ( 8l I 61 u F J W I < 11. ° ___ H I W K iz W W •• N < 2 1 O 3 r- i Q U N 3 Cg 6 < 'Q Q . . . 0 Z < LLI z 1 W a • 0t Y _ Z W O ON ERRJ = O • r N 11 ra W U ato y 0.. 2 _P y ' W _ K co — O li kr) , W. 1.`.V Cl. 4r.. x - O On 0 W !" S� oho < �. o > Q) J o h .��.�. F Z LI. tial J LL° 0 O W 0 , 3 0 Z a z� 0 ^may < a a. F 2 tCr p v, W 8E u.W F o F U ti 0 W F J 14 Z< J O 4Q S Ce W o fr m > W W Z O CC p 1Li v: W W i g .. Z F cc u) Z 0 0 Z S & ht. C 1g g • W 3 W `® u. oe f LW i = iZ 0 = c> 3 3 I t ,a M o o o U . . 0 N , " '• r O u 'CS v �l me ao Naoc2N rl N o 2N N N ° o GyO ^ Uh d o O 5 ♦ d a, C O °0 ti y O O a r o> Zi.; „o t„„4 , O 1 t►C, u i m c r v a x L. o ° V Q eg a CG °c° rz 00 0 orr �� C ' y V o� e . . a0 O �NN a _.. _ F Ca L' NN R rn • az C. 2 'nr CO) a� N o' IQ L., :74 r 11�� U r'�i N N V1 a 5 Q a a 7 4 m t G I ca Q w 44,_ b .b.b b4 a� Fr d cc Fa cm cn w r 0 w— Q ?,N P- UE.. d b L ^ I y -k' o o w Cq c� a� 7. 0. 00`° O .�.N N C m x o r.a i L ti '' Q .�..O o 'C I .0.. - OO O it - b 'C - 0. A O 0 ONN b i- m o w 0 o °`•�° N °�' .a ° ° Orn? Q r M N U U ...^ Nee. 0NeV •:7” .71 O `I Q cd C F -6 m �A N .Ni 0. 0. 0. 0. .�+ ;.d r+ O d �` < < - QCA H > W < Iz Z h E x o c .4e U~r. U o.a.01.4 Q— •grA N Q N ° m r Z,.., 1 Cd..... tn` o a Col Q O N Q UO O ti 4. , O U V b0 00 [al 71 4� rw • " Q b• $ Y d _.! �''. O OD',�O O O O W R'an i o 'C pp Ul Gz' ? r.. w U O^ N p p C .. �� f►1 0 '" as CZ VM Q U a(,w�,O O Q moi...c20-4 M N F N R O 4.a. co) o. U c j0. q� as w N o 0 O w r Or Q AC z ." ? w U 614 TY V CO r h d o '� 4 V U W Q IQ W cC E �'$, a. M [� � � Z V`C je O ren X00 o CJ H Z en � ,� �o Oma~ m S Q O.. co n . o ° Vj [- ' ►fir.. Ma el W i 1, y a 4.a o ° OC N op v .. Q4 $ v 0 o Q d a w ..en 1 o q g .a7 IO o en, . 3 = e d G z E':::= ° w q a co .. IFr L �a=# uA ° �I td �o `° c+� �] L 0.3 :: OUAv� NV Q. vits Q F 4� to F" iii CC IflA x a '� �� G 0.e") N cg d OF W O Q H ° ° co) O a o. 7 0 am p^ may = M. O a o �i y cen OC c" d E oM � O' 7 0 W c 0 �- aw MIW Uc V W d �d �' n ° °: ° a x cc oaa �� °o o w q� o .a d am - O— x o M ec o et .r �; `r 'IVw © as ww co w I Eo �u � I S A , W e A A eaea o)o c z A ao d ? © - 4. pa N m4t1^ L • O_ d W D ZZ 0 0 0 0 0 o e o 0 0 a ev M ,. oao' U .14 ,ao t. 00 E. Tr ogoi MN. bb 00. o r N a r ,r J r., ,. , o U r O W h d o o V C d d O 0 � h O C.•C L Ts x > p E I. o _ o �.. o de 1; ai Mat �... 1..4: C UD co 5"-_ OOa Ts U�� o es 0 ti N N R Q �N N 0 F IIA t-- ~ Iff1y� MCO un N" 44 W V O.a V1 t Q v *Iet ,1 Q CO V ti O W i W :a 17 -0 ^ C > EE. d E" opo opo e Q U W GA i 4. b re �— — r 0. 7 as cd = U 'C o.N C .co)6.; ; CI a6.> - C O c0W U b0b pa Q ? eN C . o C A X O , ❑ , L1i J'O [" 'ZrL I) y4.) aia pqv4. ti4' 8 ¢ c O U ^„ Or R v �; 0 cd d C .o Fy or 1... 1-. M a Zr . Q. aac. o. o x 'b .. , Zs < < < Cr H > w < ZAU <11 z ii g © 0 5" d v ° �e Z ° � Q1... o x '. Z. �° U E. U °id O— ons ' ,a= 0000F F U",w d a 3 >`•o00 co U.Z. C..)c,),•, o �iA NN W.. Va v4 �C col L. co a N - O o W o W'— U Q L° U � e a 04 co) e0 o 12.11 41 o qD � ho d do J0 o W � .t Z C 4. e mat O ea vi w .... W 4 .l t- I ? ' U A oieq .ol co Ce en C F6. C a `� O E– °;o a m 4 W r �r q N -r. c o A U o 0 A N y OQo 4 O 'p sic v F r, 44 h.eS col q .- O V ro "Ey 4, W JOS ew a a R O F W CO) - x Z y N W y o C4 8 o '�" 4 V co 4t 44 U Wo H CD X 44 IWg y'4:1 in Ch Ae co)co tea.. z '�7� �M e� M .. I o co i cco 0 In In Q ce.1 go Ly v , 0 o o iWN ,- O U Q 0 Q C MO I O y Q oZ w e .o = -4u . # p E2 w .4.vel o L. OUAv, tVV �j o Z E-, �3 =fey E.3 G j 04 F' J L� o,N N f14 N Ww Z w ��N 3 w Q CI O W O Wo QF �,r-- � � o U o ao Q .a W ✓ O co y ry cC o QC 0, oo cG 5 d E O M Z W U L V W COoc, r.Nr Q L 4, .; 04 U x "I O F . �Q o a o o � J� z �o °� Jad t� qo W j qi � W ii r V[/] LL 70 CQ a �" ...O b•C = W O a s W W o 0 s.: C > o a ,Z 4 vs . E o 7. Z F= ZZ Na 0.e U -- i Q O Q - j 0 0.N1 C__J_ CO a er /i yi i t,,,, cri N li'; o %f,'sY49iU1mflUi ' � ;• liiii ( '1 111 ,I .w,w. •r 'f‘.,;;:.;;;,,,,,,,,;,/,,', lT;I },, £3dF„fi IEtE1.1 bi t , ` /,/CDi ''141,,,!Ip, itIilfli,E, . 'il't/tft1/iiiiiiiiiiiliizi1 .,i i .;} es LJ 1 s ,..I 13 96 4a..' ,,, o \ 4:\jil. C,3 'E 404 ^ • , ;iia 4$,tti. Ci roc (0,02RI I— Z , _ 5 Iw CI. o oaooa NN M00,.. \�7 6qy K u.^i ,moi N tI Q en N =A Q eL1o e 1,44 r4IQ 5 Q QwQ L� OEv 09e '',1i U Eo WA Q = T = r0i..:i 9E E. c (P, � w O Ic. nw O ;Li tes-0 o . ; C7c 1;,.. " U > > � O E > > bM 0 g ,v a y 70) 0 U Ncx d j Ow N o 0. a a� U , b co y >- t) 7 X o o > a COv•- •- o O C rij ¢ ¢ Lc�>- QwwUUoO ¢ C1 UU j• ^ 7,ogo Au y � „co) •-•;... "R N N yO O 1 y . L. Q I� [p C '� O d C !� U Ic) Q N 4'E U w .. E o0 3 en en °� Q ` C 4 > o m «7. Ccon o, dj I�Q wU > ._. C7d A 5?-z z .._ d d _ —1q o :1' 0., c _c v'Ai u a h s„o lV s rLes= a .. E.'ti N i. ° Ooa•`va V L" ey U .••i M l- V) M M ..i ,� ,� O N N O - �T w . E .�.. i0 e., �' ,•� O O N 7 N O O O O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 C.:1 U u �.,., ;3 '" � ¢ co u ¢ w •� x aQ .a I' Q'w w a•,oa ! ' ~ ' X33 2 > 33wwa� �',`, _ �" $ " � .1 - O o fi — ti Q•.o .o rn U o .o •o •`o_ u.. F- Cq W x >G v) .-‘2 S. O .y w = 'O •`' v :; 0 o a`i a`i a� a`i is is co ca ca ca ca t v aai U vt z v�Ca ,.� o U o 0 0 0 o a .. d z OO i .. 8O U X X O O a. . _ • 0 _ _ _ H F N [— F- as ae _i= OA w w�__ - • IoF W o z .„,jW W W w 1 • d .� 0 a w 1 Wco 1 :,„\\. . . . . . . . . 3.r. l . . (-7_,,.. 2 v� 0 i J y a 7 (3) \4--,, ��! M I U f N V J 2• d 1N. \' ', p c2 - . Q 0 0 ¢ f, a w Q C 0 I > 00m N rb . © ›- c. c<1 • 1 jI W J O O O D U U I Sfv + �i l u d r) = 0 0 U U • . c .i .e 3 m m w Z 0 IX Cr Z N I g 'o y 0 oI S < J 7 7 w I �- c J m a a ¢ O E a 3 m o H ci I I I I I 1 - - I — I I O O I I c' c • Icam 0 tin w �¢ '.. ‘% CC W I l i I o ( 0 - x I I a a i j � Z 1 j I o Lt J � 1 `o i1 j rI S % I a , y 1 - 0- V U ... E I o g i n 01 E E I w .5. o 0 1_ 1 2 1 1 1 I 0 I I < I V w N N N N N H N < 0 I 1 1 .0 _t., Z w w l 1I- , M Z 3 31 {6 I 1 W I I .14 4.1I I IW I 3 m E 1.4 m I : T c F 3'3 LL MI.: i K• U •'I J E o E e I° c b b o j I w a. °o c o z° E, a O E _ LL x x x c 'o ., I I < O J N rl� NI- e + uo c s sl o ..Ilii vt �I Q I I I I 1.- 10 Q W v) mlin,01. ini3 3 z° m' m m' 1--1`�i1- ''-1 '2 I I i I r ^� ~1 W I �{ • i d 1 L } . I I ) I ` . 11 T I I i , I U ',I ( NII I �I LL I I I W^�0 u, I I I Z I z r I �` �yI z j , I I Q i ? o I I j l 0 I Q 1 I I1 a i = 0 I x 111 ii I W I W E x 'Io = I i di i21 i xoIoJ I I v o �i �I " m Om F• h de E ■ co LL :ooE u 1 li .'mz 1 a1033 1 .. xmR y olm I EIMIc 9 U - .. G 9. O o o - g j o cc r c c `n �. Y d N 1 I SIN 2 < d Z 0 � W LL's Z m� l r N N 1 I 0 3 i t W I y . ` U z_ z z ‘,- .. U I 0 0 — 4i1 = W y e Y E E . X L al c 0 I 1-, 4 • lt. m to 3 3 F• . yi 24 m 8 n to1v)iv) X 1 : �I o 0 0 c g p" ± i E W a 1 I ,. EE i 0 •n..I E 1 L 2 a _n I E cp I i 2 c 3 N P! O 1� 0 N m W 0 8 8 O m h � m1. 8 HI AIi ° °I Iii II `I31<i NIH 8 S1.1 $IW dIX .2IN c O o 0 0 0 O V 0 0 O _- -__ 0 .__ © r o r E. m ao v r M ao ,y h N N V. y N N c VII) C Q o N .n. do °V ' n rj O O CIO j � v O 5 d•7. c N b Ti 1 y i O d�T. o� SIL 1 U w O O u C-1 V1 y i 3; N M. �v rti y .+ 4. a O v r C cc ,�„ EL. uL.w ei 5i o Is co Q At p;oC°.OG a i.�l e e e U tt O ra a �. tin 4:' fir' A ►� 1U=o7)v °"° e lti rjl 'ii ; UN 0. NEO.. o0 0 Fi es y , > 7 6> 7 1 Q Q x `3, A c Un doo oWd a W b � � au a > � � ts co) ca O �` '" r y a 7 c�i as a a N ' 141 PI�^r? e v .� > > cu c 4 v1 O o, .. O CI > > 7 p,,, 'L 0 _ UENo ea vlfy J nn i b4 �� -o > .7)) w L �Q O �:oo W X O a ° °' 000 I: ":':t. ti NN 1,_, �. .. -, ti 00 V o ,�M �° Lv onoo ' s> ta ami C) Aa, o c z QMNN Q ,1,,4 rn rn rn v� rn '.. �, 04 o a � dQoesWQ Q Q F- > IZ pzF gCi AY � z Adm o Q CFS�� �I a Z ocm>� E 0 es ., o o �-.e;s o U AwFSC � •o CO m to 3 woe t co so o d E cn CL . vNI .. h QaA ANN O UnziaIXaF, w� E k v1 t e Vec1Qn m 4 g C31 0_ , !o k © m ' 7 W. –04 C7 000000 W Ch v n j .,., W _z S ee0000 d o U \ `•1 0 9 cIp� 4no —O' F ° 000 Q U [W, Oa p QNN ° IF Q Q N00 NQ a 1:1q o� s0 Gy ,.i oo w I cc o0o a O Nooses= 0.1 ro w 'b '�i '� ,\ RO�ON N 4 4 W U U k.oi w W a o rn 0 a s N 7 r W o O 'a E y'N h y .7 O 1 0 00 �', L.7 V jIN O o w !— N c� Ot Ma " eO' kr,-. o � � `d A Q�U c ; oo .. ao Q 4, .4 a.a r r:, c .r. � ccWt:7 .a ° o o o»' Q pp M 00OC o q, c d e d o o O a ozC o ;, Er G L. h a:fl a ,O [�. W d W .s1 7 k°.cc o c6 p 'O vdoa ° Q on W v1 a, dOW U oC.)Acn7 t•-•4 C.5 Z z a Q3CaxF- Q A Z rN F•i . II ? Nlo aW Ez A Z = q•N MNNOO �� O64Gk• 0.04 zW O R m N a w a 3 v; W Wo x 0 QF. _ M O O V C = oo Z W w cs00000 a',)'-e-; o, C O Q U n. r W a QNNNNN > o l� w F, L 0 ►•' N oo C x'.N NOO 5 R o 4' c.4t. OZW Q o p °� Cl) o �0 •e0000 Qw v IZ S O 3 �il S F" 4 v)d ..1 n W N c.n ,4 .7� 00 0d [rte v_� O S NNN.. 1 = UCA p a CA C.1) S o C S 7Z d N Gd I VD..o°'=o Gz, c, wY d ° . ! ' d A d; dd , z .1 w -- > .N. C 4czoNNONON a le ':. a � – 3d_ 77 _ � _3 k_ Q�w mmmms anal.. O M N Q O N o 01 o N ��j°}I,j1 j3ii § I 3„,. a N. 4* 171 71 1)40'' ''11 i I ill 14 f 11%1 1 111 iblif Q . I qpip ligi i unlyellw 13, :ell Ili 1 hi r I III li lit, v- ..4- li ' lilt t ; U ry m j LLmD LL G� .,v- `° 1 5 oIa. N a 7 y N00� Q O R N lh NI d .t4 LL O 0 U.~r —N 1 S Q o y0 i-. i r. o 4 O W e- r , fi Q e AC 'Z1 a M aa\V oeraooC -4 ,y a V. - e o oU�p i 'T00 o 7,'"' W W 7! Q I v i E..L.) oo E � .� Q I` �i x 3 L o O ci c.; o.a5 m a E ...00 A !� RRNT w Op r a U o I 4T) O ig ;;U— o fV ',moi oo�oM o 0 N 01 E raw airs: o "a0 •.c.• a, a ca *.VOO a !'�'.� Q' iel qn. - O U "C) -54,)f o� 0.oa= 'O � aaUU I+� QN NN r �t Vw a tsp co UocGo EF.voq :°oOEEoo 'LlLo o U • a ' U �Q Q 112›. wwUoOd02 •4UU ' r �iU Q opoe vM el L ~ j e T, m J, E . A E. z o .E i Q • O ."o".:: a w r o `o ao to °� p Z4 r _ a a d 'E'',1 aEe 'n ° 0 0 0 > i 20 2 a �O w X U > v < ' A U Z z d d L fi a e rr E" O o O'fl d v cc• Q C .� O O N ? N O O O O 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 D O �,Lr7 r O O O Q CO ¢ COy t a'z c: y ` C o . o y 0 k ti 0 UNrs,oaww C 3 Q € LI. E ,E, ti O r E 2 0 3 3 'w w 8 45. .. ,... . n .,,,, ,,„ 8 Q v • J ., v a.2 .2 h U o `0 D o w ( >,al co x X v, v c '8 o Tw •p a 3 t5 g 8 Y u u d w 7" is io 'a r 5 u U c F•V]X U _._ V] C7v] O W W OGa S - .... o- FFHEoLO �E w d400 00W6i,� f- Cr' . `� , _ _ _ 3 Mp cD c� c� ci c� cs M co)o N N J 0 W N y _, OJ W N , J W V/ , -J W N N 0 W N V) j co r O 0 W H j r r O O 0 I.-- j m r O 0 ¢ r CO 1- O O ¢ r`- CO r O 0 Cr r -' r r O 0 C r < O OJ H = Q 00 O OJ h = < 00 O O OJ h Z < Or C O OJ H Z < Or o O OJ H mc-2, ,, 3 0 O r Z 0 O = r 0 O H - < r A I ct L i14 W I 61 I 6l I 6l I 6l I 6l I 6l u J o I Z EL ° R U) 4 EL N 0 • W N Cr• Ix ¢ 0 U H 3 Se . < , Q a c DC.0 O F. Q ' ^ O U tS d -} W Zd11.1 0) ZS J J 0 Cr 0 J _ Z N g Za = a O J 1:t Ci N O Al / W riri a c— < 0 et ' W W !^� W 0 - 0O 0 , 0 A • 000- C W !i I -4 J ''1 r o� -- n CO . CC - <Q, Z Y p r r Z W 0 CI .v , W U 3L.) , , IJ O W F- ILu Z =C 0 u. 1Z O _ I CC ( ws ( y 0 7 tn I I < a • tr W ~-I Ck tL d -9 O W v 1 X 0 W �� r 0 N W U cc < U F CC CC ` < W W W Z O CC U) 0 0 �s u) N: D \ •r-I W W la M U <'. N r " oc < co ta Z S Z W rx W CI - S oWI `� & O F z 0 s c.. d 3 ; ( u.